December 9th, 2019
Published on June 6th, 2018 | by Georgia Archonti0
Netherlands: Council of State rules that detention under Dublin III Regulation is unlawful if applicant is not given the opportunity to be heard
On 2 May 2018, the Dutch Council of State ruled against the State Secretary for Justice and Security and upheld the ruling of the District Court of The Hague in finding that applicants under the Dublin III Regulation cannot be detained prior to being given the opportunity to be heard. The ruling directly refers to the current practice of the Dutch national authorities, under which a legally residing applicant falling under the Dublin III Regulation can be placed in detention at “asylum seekers’ centre” prior to being given the chance to be heard and is later transferred to a detention centre where a hearing is then conducted as soon as possible.
The Council of State concurred with the lower court that Article 5(2) of the Dutch Aliens Decree 2000, which establishes that a third country national must be heard prior to be detained under Article 59 of the Aliens Act, should be the general rule and can only be circumvented under the exceptional circumstances laid down in that Decree. This exceptional circumstance cannot be adopted as a general rule for all those applicants who are legally residing and are placed in detention pursuant to Section 59(1)(a) of the Aliens Act 2000.
For further information click here…